Cannot get app to display full width

[dmitcha1]

I have tried every step provided in the board that I can find, but my app will not display full-width. 

1. My Settings/Screen Size + Orientation settings are: 16:9 (Default), Scale to Fit Off, Lock Aspect Ratio Off.
2. When I open the published app, I click Fit to Screen
3. Each of my screens have a width setting of Max(App.Width, App.DesignWidth) and a height setting of Max(App.Height, App.DesignHeight)

I cannot get the app to resize to fit my screen. 

Troubleshooting:

• I built a test app with just a blank screen, filled that with a background color, then placed two controls on those. They also stop at 1366.
• I set the dimensions to 1920x1080. Everything expanded to fill that screen. When I reset to 16:9, no more resizing.
• I tested a PA template, and it does autoresize in my screen. Those screens are set to the Max formulas, and the controls have fixed dimensions (it wasn't written to be responsive), but it still resized without clicking Fit to Screen.

I thought it might be something buggy in components, but even when I built the new app without them, it didn't autofit. 

• I changed my component header width to: Max(App.Width, App.DesignWidth). The headers then resized to fill the screen, but the screens underneath now shrunk fully flush left and no longer filled even the height of the window.
• I deleted the components, turned off components and turned off all preview options. The screen remained flush left and at a reduced size.

Is there anything else that might make this work?

Also, is there a way to set Preview to full-screen?

Thanks.

[Pstork1]

First, if you haven't read the article on Power Apps Responsive design here it is.

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/powerapps/maker/canvas-apps/create-responsive-layout

Otherwise, the one thing that I do differently is that after turning off scale to fit I always use Custom for the screen size.  Using 16:9 means that it will try to impose that aspect ratio on the screen no matter what the width setting is.  With Custom it gives you the freedom to change both at runtime.  Just type in numbers that make sense on your current monitor while designing and then set them in the app programmatically.  That will override your custom settings.  

[dmitcha1]

I see, thanks - that may be why it worked with Custom set to 1920x1080.

I don't understand specifically how to do the latter half of this:

---

@Pstork1 wrote:

Just type in numbers that make sense on your current monitor while designing and then set them in the app programmatically.  That will override your custom settings.  

---

When I first reviewed the responsive settings, it was an enormous task to manually set every control in the frame. But when I launch sample apps, they have 16:9 set as default size and all of the controls are fixed dimensions, but they immediately resize in my screen. 

How does one set autofit screen in the app programmatically? Is there some way other than manually setting every control on every screen to relative size and width? And do you understand why the sample templates work with autofit?

Thanks.

[Pstork1]

A couple of points.  If you are on a 16:9 screen then having autoresize turned on will autoresize for you screen.  But that's not responsive since if you are on a 4:3 screen it will autoresize to make sure that a 4:3 resolution will fit on your screen.  That will leave space at either the sides or the top.  To do full responsive so the app will adapt to whatever screen size you are in you do have to set the dimensions of the Screen and container objects manually in the code.  Everything else is set relative to them by using Parent.something or recognizing that the X and Y are relative to the parent.  There is no magic fix for that.  Autoresize is easy and will give good results, but it won't be perfect on all screens. Using a fixed resolution or screen fit ratio won't fill the whole screen on every screen.

[dmitcha]

Thank you for responding. Setting magic fixes aside, I am hoping someone just has an explanation: In the sample templates I've reviewed, all have set each screen to max width and height, but none have set any controls on the page to relative settings. Each of these has auto-resized to fill my 27" monitor. My app, constructed identically, does not.


If you, or anyone, has seen the same discrepancy by briefly examining the sample templates that go full screen without individually responsive controls, and figured it out, I would appreciate that understanding.

[dmitcha1]

If it's useful for anyone trying to troubleshoot, here are design settings from a sample template:

1. The screen settings (responsive)
2. The control settings (fixed) - I can only upload one, per attachment limits, but all are the same
3. The published view (fit to screen)

I am trying to understand this because my published view dimensions keep changing. Sometimes it is centered with margins, right now it is flushed left, etc. So I suspect there is a div or some other design issue that needs to be addressed. This happens frequently in Oxygen Builder, which I use for WP design, and carefully working through Inspect Element usually identifies the culprit. Inspect Element tweaks haven't corrected screens yet.

Thank you for any insights anyone can share about why this works for the template.

[Pstork1]

Its the ratio of the Pixel height vs. width that matters, not that its a 27" monitor.  If the ratio is 4:3 (width vs height) then that setting will fill the screen, assuming scale to fit is turned on.  If the ratio is 16:9 then that setting will fill the screen. But if the screen is set to one of those with scale to fit and the ratio of the monitor doesn't match the setting then you will get white space.  That's where responsive comes in.  If you turn off the ratios and scaling settings then you can set the position and size of all the controls on the screen using formulas.

For the templates, I suspect your 27" monitor matches the pixel ratio that was used in the template.  So it works.

[dmitcha1]

We are not discussing the same issue.

I am not confused by how responsive design works, which is what you are trying to assist with. I understand responsive design principles and screen ratios.

Instead, I am confused by the discrepancy between the behavior of two identical apps. As I mentioned, the app that is not resizing is identical in settings to the app that is resizing. That is what I am solving for. 

Further, at some point in editing, the non-resizing app further breaks the container and flushes fully left. In other template-driven software, such breaks frequently are caused by a setting in a single div (or here, control). 

If anyone has experienced this and has read the content of my posts, any insights would be great. Thanks.

If anyone has

[Pstork1]

Resizing aside for the moment, one of the things that breaks placement is renaming screens.  If you create a screen exactly the way you want it to look, duplicate it, and then rename the duplicate a lot of the controls will re-align.  This has been reported and is a known issue.

In terms of two different apps not following the same rule set, I would have to see the two apps to track down why they behave differently.  But there is some setting that is different. There are a lot of things other than X, Y, Width, and Height that will affect the screen. That's why I usually go to the trouble of doing some level of responsive design.

[dmitcha]

Thanks, and exactly, it's the settings I've been stepping through, but let me give this insight a try next. There are multiple cloned and renamed edited screens in the app. I am going to test in a fresh app to see if not renaming leaves the screen placement intact and, in turn, might even affect resizing.