cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Reply
sopatte
Microsoft
Microsoft

Delegation warning doesn't make sense

 

 

 

    Set(Prefixes,
        Coalesce(
            LookUp(Metadata,
                Title = "Prefixes|" & MyFilter.Value,
                Data
            ),
            MyFilter.Value
        )
    );
    Clear(Cache);
    ForAll(Split(Prefixes,","),
        Collect(Cache,
            Filter(MyDataSource,
                StartsWith(Title, Result) // Delegation Warning
            )
        )
    )

 

 

 

 

This delegation warning doesn't make sense; StartsWith is delegable, and "Result" evaluates to a static string at runtime for each call to Filter. MyDataSource doesn't have a column named Result so there is no name collision. This seems like a bug.

6 REPLIES 6
RandyHayes
Super User
Super User

@sopatte 

You are looking at the ForAll as a ForLoop.  It is not, it is a function that returns a table of records.  In your case, it is going to return a table with multiple rows that have records with a Value column that will be complete copies of your Cache table.

 

What you are trying to do is not going to be delegable!

 

Is there any pre-filtering of the datasource that can be applied prior to filtering in your formula?

I assume that delegation and record limit are important in your app as you have surfaced this question.

_____________________________________________________________________________________
Digging it? - Click on the Thumbs Up below. Solved your problem? - Click on Accept as Solution below. Others seeking the same answers will be happy you did.
NOTE: My normal response times will be Mon to Fri from 1 PM to 10 PM UTC (and lots of other times too!)
Check out my PowerApps Videos too! And, follow me on Twitter @RandyHayes

Really want to show your appreciation? Buy Me A Cup Of Coffee!
sopatte
Microsoft
Microsoft

@RandyHayes,
Respectfully, in my mind, if the data passed to Filter is contained completely in the app prior to delegation, i.e. there's nothing to guess about at runtime, to pass up to the server and say, '[Hey server, you calculate this thing because Idk what it is at this time]", for example it includes a part of the record itself, then to say we can't delegate this comparison to a known string even though we can delegate to this other known string, that's a bug.

I came up with another case that illustrates my point even more clearly. 

 

 

Set(Prefix, SomeOtherVariable & "/");
ClearCollect(Cache,
    Filter(MyDataSource,
        StartsWith(Title, Prefix) // No problem
    )
);
ClearCollect(Cache2,
    Filter(MyDataSource,
        StartsWith(Title, SomeOtherVariable & "/") // Delegation warning
    )
);
ClearCollect(Cache2,
    Filter(MyDataSource,
        StartsWith(Title, "AB") // No problem
    )
);
ClearCollect(Cache2,
    Filter(MyDataSource,
        StartsWith(Title, "A" & "B") // Delegation warning
    )
);

 

 

No ForAll to confuse the issue here. These last Filter calls should be semantically identical. Quoting the delegation documentation: "You can also use portions of your formula that evaluate to a constant value for all records. For example, Left( Language(), 2 )Date( 2019, 3, 31 ), and Today() don't depend on any columns of the record and, therefore, return the same value for all records. These values can be sent to the data source as a constant and won't block delegation." "A" & "B" is such a case. This is a bug. This one can be worked around, but it's still a bug.

Also, nothwithstanding it being a function that sometimes returns a table ForAll is like a for loop. In my original example, Filter gets called once for every comma-separated value in Prefixes (I checked in Monitor), and delegation doesn't happen in each call, even though StartsWith is delegable and its second argument doesn't reference any fields of MyDataSource and can be resolved to a static string to be passed to the data source at runtime. This is not due to some limitation of the data source; that's a bug in Power Apps.

chathway2
Frequent Visitor

I don't get this either! I'm trying to get a collection of all SharePoint items in list, so to avoid 500 limit using a ForAll to collect each item that starts with A through Z. The below returns 500 limit.

 

 

ForAll(Sequence(26,65) As letter,
    With({currentLetter:Char(letter.Value)},
         Collect(myUsers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,currentLetter))) //delegation warning
  )
)

 

 

If I replace currentLetter with a string value e.g. "A" then it loops 26 times creating 26 collection items for each item that starts with A!  no delegation warning.

 

I thought only the Filter function would delegate to SharePoint? on each loop iteration delegating the Filter query to SharePoint with the current item (currentLetter) 🤷‍

 

What does the below mean? The field name (Title) does not appear in the second argument (A-Z)

 

chathway2_0-1650552182203.png

 

chathway2
Frequent Visitor

This works fine! 😩

ClearCollect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"A")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"B")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"C")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"D")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"E")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"F")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"G")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"H")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"I")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"J")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"K")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"L")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"M")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"N")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"O")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"P")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"Q")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"R")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"S")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"T")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"U")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"V")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"W")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"X")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"Y")));
Collect(Myusers,Filter(permStaff,StartsWith(Title,"Z")))

 

RandyHayes
Super User
Super User

@chathway2 

If you are experiencing a particular issue with your formulas, you might want to post a new message on it as this one is a little old at this point.

 

However, in reviewing your posts, yes, this is not something you can delegate.  You are trying to delegate multiple criteria (i.e. multiple filters).  You cannot do that.  You can delegate complex criteria in certain ways, but it all boils it down to a single filter/selection.  In your case, you are trying to force the formula editor to make a filter/select to the datasource that would always require at least 26 different filter/selects...that you cannot do.

 

In other words - Whenever the formula editor encounters a Filter statement, it tries to "package" it in a way that will produce one query based on what you want.  In your case, it would have to produce 26 of them, and that is not supported.

 

I hope this is helpful for you.

_____________________________________________________________________________________
Digging it? - Click on the Thumbs Up below. Solved your problem? - Click on Accept as Solution below. Others seeking the same answers will be happy you did.
NOTE: My normal response times will be Mon to Fri from 1 PM to 10 PM UTC (and lots of other times too!)
Check out my PowerApps Videos too! And, follow me on Twitter @RandyHayes

Really want to show your appreciation? Buy Me A Cup Of Coffee!

Thanks for the explanation @RandyHayes .    It's a bit counterintuitive as would expect the only the Filter statement to be delegated to SharePoint however, I understand your statement regarding it trying to 'package' the whole ForAll command into a single command which it cannot do.

 

I'll work around it the long way around for now.

Helpful resources

Announcements

Power Platform Connections - Episode 7 | March 30, 2023

Episode Seven of Power Platform Connections sees David Warner and Hugo Bernier talk to Microsoft MVP Dian Taylor, alongside the latest news, product reviews, and community blogs.     Use the hashtag #PowerPlatformConnects on social media for a chance to have your work featured on the show!      Show schedule in this episode:    0:00 Cold Open 00:30 Show Intro 01:02 Dian Taylor Interview 18:03 Blogs & Articles 26:55 Outro & Bloopers    Check out the blogs and articles featured in this week’s episode:    https://francomusso.com/create-a-drag-and-drop-experience-to-upload-case-attachments @crmbizcoach https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3522H834Ro​/  @pranavkhuranauk https://github.com/pnp/powerapps-designtoolkit/tree/main/materialdesign%20components @MMe2K​ https://2die4it.com/2023/03/27/populate-a-dynamic-microsoft-word-template-in-power-automate-flow/ @StefanS365 https://d365goddess.com/viva-sales-administrator-settings/ @D365Goddess https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=megel.mme2k-powerapps-helper#Visualize_Dataverse... @MMe2K    Action requested:  Feel free to provide feedback on how we can make our community more inclusive and diverse.    This episode premiered live on our YouTube at 12pm PST on Thursday 30th March 2023.    Video series available at Power Platform Community YouTube channel.    Upcoming events:  Business Applications Launch – April 4th – Free and Virtual! M365 Conference - May 1-5th - Las Vegas Power Apps Developers Summit – May 19-20th - London European Power Platform conference – Jun. 20-22nd - Dublin Microsoft Power Platform Conference – Oct. 3-5th - Las Vegas    Join our Communities:  Power Apps Community Power Automate Community Power Virtual Agents Community Power Pages Community    If you’d like to hear from a specific community member in an upcoming recording and/or have specific questions for the Power Platform Connections team, please let us know. We will do our best to address all your requests or questions.   

Announcing | Super Users - 2023 Season 1

Super Users – 2023 Season 1    We are excited to kick off the Power Users Super User Program for 2023 - Season 1.  The Power Platform Super Users have done an amazing job in keeping the Power Platform communities helpful, accurate and responsive. We would like to send these amazing folks a big THANK YOU for their efforts.      Super User Season 1 | Contributions July 1, 2022 – December 31, 2022  Super User Season 2 | Contributions January 1, 2023 – June 30, 2023    Curious what a Super User is? Super Users are especially active community members who are eager to help others with their community questions. There are 2 Super User seasons in a year, and we monitor the community for new potential Super Users at the end of each season. Super Users are recognized in the community with both a rank name and icon next to their username, and a seasonal badge on their profile.    Power Apps  Power Automate  Power Virtual Agents  Power Pages  Pstork1*  Pstork1*  Pstork1*  OliverRodrigues  BCBuizer  Expiscornovus*  Expiscornovus*  ragavanrajan  AhmedSalih  grantjenkins  renatoromao    Mira_Ghaly*  Mira_Ghaly*      Sundeep_Malik*  Sundeep_Malik*      SudeepGhatakNZ*  SudeepGhatakNZ*      StretchFredrik*  StretchFredrik*      365-Assist*  365-Assist*      cha_cha  ekarim2020      timl  Hardesh15      iAm_ManCat  annajhaveri      SebS  Rhiassuring      LaurensM  abm      TheRobRush  Ankesh_49      WiZey  lbendlin      Nogueira1306  Kaif_Siddique      victorcp  RobElliott      dpoggemann  srduval      SBax  CFernandes      Roverandom  schwibach      Akser  CraigStewart      PowerRanger  MichaelAnnis      subsguts  David_MA      EricRegnier  edgonzales      zmansuri  GeorgiosG      ChrisPiasecki  ryule      AmDev  fchopo      phipps0218  tom_riha      theapurva  takolota     Akash17  momlo     BCLS776  Shuvam-rpa     rampprakash  ScottShearer     Rusk  ChristianAbata     cchannon  Koen5     a33ik   Heartholme     AaronKnox        Matren        Alex_10        Jeff_Thorpe        poweractivate        Ramole        DianaBirkelbach        DavidZoon        AJ_Z        PriyankaGeethik        BrianS        StalinPonnusamy        HamidBee        CNT        Anonymous_Hippo        Anchov        KeithAtherton        alaabitar        Tolu_Victor        KRider        sperry1625        IPC_ahaas      zuurg    rubin_boer   cwebb365   Dorrinda   G1124   Gabibalaban   Manan-Malhotra   jcfDaniel   WarrenBelz   Waegemma      If an * is at the end of a user's name this means they are a Multi Super User, in more than one community. Please note this is not the final list, as we are pending a few acceptances.  Once they are received the list will be updated. 

Microsoft Power Platform Conference | Registration Open | Oct. 3-5 2023

We are so excited to see you for the Microsoft Power Platform Conference in Las Vegas October 3-5 2023! But first, let's take a look back at some fun moments and the best community in tech from MPPC 2022 in Orlando, Florida.   Featuring guest speakers such as Charles Lamanna, Heather Cook, Julie Strauss, Nirav Shah, Ryan Cunningham, Sangya Singh, Stephen Siciliano, Hugo Bernier and many more.   Register today: https://www.powerplatformconf.com/   

Check out the new Power Platform Communities Front Door Experience!

We are excited to share the ‘Power Platform Communities Front Door’ experience with you!   Front Door brings together content from all the Power Platform communities into a single place for our community members, customers and low-code, no-code enthusiasts to learn, share and engage with peers, advocates, community program managers and our product team members. There are a host of features and new capabilities now available on Power Platform Communities Front Door to make content more discoverable for all power product community users which includes ForumsUser GroupsEventsCommunity highlightsCommunity by numbersLinks to all communities Users can see top discussions from across all the Power Platform communities and easily navigate to the latest or trending posts for further interaction. Additionally, they can filter to individual products as well.       Users can filter and browse the user group events from all power platform products with feature parity to existing community user group experience and added filtering capabilities.     Users can now explore user groups on the Power Platform Front Door landing page with capability to view all products in Power Platform.    Explore Power Platform Communities Front Door today. Visit Power Platform Community Front door to easily navigate to the different product communities, view a roll up of user groups, events and forums.

Welcome to the Power Apps Community

Welcome! Congratulations on joining the Microsoft Power Apps community! You are now a part of a vibrant group of peers and industry experts who are here to network, share knowledge, and even have a little fun! Now that you are a member, you can enjoy the following resources:   The Microsoft Power Apps Community Forums If you are looking for support with any part of Microsoft Power Apps, our forums are the place to go. They are titled "Get Help with Microsoft Power Apps " and there you will find thousands of technical professionals with years of experience who are ready and eager to answer your questions. You now have the ability to post, reply and give "kudos" on the Power Apps community forums! Make sure you conduct a quick search before creating a new post because your question may have already been asked and answered!   Microsoft Power Apps IdeasDo you have an idea to improve the Microsoft Power Apps experience, or a feature request for future product updates? Then the "Power Apps Ideas" section is where you can contribute your suggestions and vote for ideas posted by other community members. We constantly look to the most voted Ideas when planning updates, so your suggestions and votes will always make a difference.   Community Blog & NewsOver the years, more than 600 Power Apps Community Blog Articles have been written and published by our thriving community. Our community members have learned some excellent tips and have keen insights on building Power Apps. On the Power Apps Community Blog, read the latest Power Apps related posts from our community blog authors around the world. Let us know if you would like to become an author and contribute your own writing — everything Power Apps related is welcome!   Power Apps Samples, Learning and Videos GalleriesOur galleries have a little bit of everything to do with Power Apps. Our galleries are great for finding inspiration for your next app or component. You can view, comment and kudo the apps and component gallery to see what others have created! Or share Power Apps that you have created with other Power Apps enthusiasts. Along with all of that awesome content, there is the Power Apps Community Video & MBAS gallery where you can watch tutorials and demos by Microsoft staff, partners, and community gurus in our community video gallery.   Again, we are excited to welcome you to the Microsoft Power Apps community family! Whether you are brand new to the world of process automation or you are a seasoned Power Apps veteran. Our goal is to shape the community to be your ‘go to’ for support, networking, education, inspiration and encouragement as we enjoy this adventure together!   Let us know in the Community Feedback if you have any questions or comments about your community experience.To learn more about the community and your account be sure to visit our Community Support Area boards to learn more! We look forward to seeing you in the Power Apps Community!The Power Apps Team

Top Solution Authors
Top Kudoed Authors
Users online (2,817)