cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Reply
Gary_Eden
Helper V
Helper V

PowerApps native code Versus offloading to Power Automate

We have a debate going on between members of my Power Platform developer team and we are pretty much split down the middle.

 

The debate is when should you off-load actions from Power Apps to Power Automate.

The divide is split around which performs faster/better and which is more stable/reliable/easier to fix.

 

I expect there is no absolute but the current debate revolves around sending email confirmations following user actions within an app (in this example reserving a desk in our desk booking app).

 

The current set up is sending the composed email using Office365Outlook.SendEmailV2(), there are several options and dynamic values that are collected as part of the composing process. These values (plus a few extra ones) are saved to either Dataverse or Azure SQL (the app can run on either), on success the email is sent - the patch is wrapped in a variable (if empty the patch failed and an error message is displayed).

 

The argument for using the PowerApp to send the email is that all the information is there at the moment of execution, so it makes sense to send the email as part of a single transaction, on success.

 

The argument for using Power Automate is to take the load away from the app and apply a trigger on the database to start the Flow, collect the data (that's just been saved in the table) and then send the email.

  

I've tried to be unbiased in the above but to be open, I'm for using Office365Outlook.SendEmailV2() as I've had too many experiences with Flows breaking following Microsoft updates, plus it's easy to add extra bits later on if needed. 

 

I do use flow from time to time and I'm open minded about changing over if there is an overwhelming and convincing reason to switch over from using Office365Outlook.SendEmailV2() and similar.

4 REPLIES 4
cchannon
Multi Super User
Multi Super User

I, too, generally prefer to keep the logic within PowerFx where possible. A couple additional reasons you didn't mention:

  • Flow runs aren't free. Once you reach your monthly cap based on user headcount you need to start paying for additional runs
  • Offloading to Flow adds moving pieces to the solution; your flow needs to be in the environment, it needs to be turned On, the user needs to have appropriate privs to execute it...
TheRobRush
Super User
Super User

I, personally, find that complex requests tend to be better in PowerAutomate but I assume most  people will have their own opinion case by case. I've never had a flow break, a little curious what actions you take where that has been a common issue. Sending a lot of data via PowerApps can faill slightly more often due to hiccups/drops in signal etc and I find it's just often more reliable to send one small bit of data, a record ID, or a json string with a few bits of the data, and then letting powerautomate handle it all in the cloud where there is no reliance on signal strength.

_____________________________________________________________________________________
Like my answer? - Hit that Thumbs Up. Resolved the Issue? - Hit Accept as Solution.
This helps others find solutions to future issues!
Gary_Eden
Helper V
Helper V

Two replies and it's 50/50.

Valid points for both approaches.

Interestingly for the forum the answer is 'it depends', there isn't any right or wrong way and I suspect there is no compelling argument to use one route over the other.

 

For others who may find this post, I won't accept one as a solution as they could be both correct or both wrong... it simply depends.

 

The important thing is 'does it work', if it does it's most likely the right solution for your specific instance.

I'm sure the debate will continue within my team for a long time to come.

TheRobRush
Super User
Super User

100% it is for sure a per use question.

 

And in some cases the answer can even be BOTH.

 

For example. I have one high traffic app. It has to be precise, and we cannot wait on it. It scans in arrivals in a garage, that is about 50 feet underground, and under who knows how thick a layer of concrete as it is below about 5 other levels of garage. During testing I found that it could, on occasion be an issue.

 

So in this scenarios the model I rolled out incorporated the ID number of the record associated with the parking pass, arrival date, location etc into the QR code so the initial scan at user level would have the most pertinent information baked physically right there into the code. It then wraps a normal patch into an IfError(Patch()) so that if that fails it drops this scan info into a local collection and turns on a time that begins running and every 5 seconds checks to see if the 'Queue' collection is empty, if it is not it sends the next item in the queue to flow, and if the flow returns back a success notification it removes this item from the Queue, timer keeps running and it checks again in case there are multiple items queued. When it sees queue is empty it then turns the timer off until another failure happens starting it off running again.

Might be a little overkill, but in that specific situation it brought me some piece of mind, and after those few failures that prompted this in the exploration/testing phase since launching with these methods in place to handle unexpected drops in signal etc there has not been a single failure usage wise in over a year now. So, for me, worth that little extra work when setting up.

_____________________________________________________________________________________
Like my answer? - Hit that Thumbs Up. Resolved the Issue? - Hit Accept as Solution.
This helps others find solutions to future issues!

Helpful resources

Announcements

Celebrating the May Super User of the Month: Laurens Martens

  @LaurensM  is an exceptional contributor to the Power Platform Community. Super Users like Laurens inspire others through their example, encouragement, and active participation. We are excited to celebrated Laurens as our Super User of the Month for May 2024.   Consistent Engagement:  He consistently engages with the community by answering forum questions, sharing insights, and providing solutions. Laurens dedication helps other users find answers and overcome challenges.   Community Expertise: As a Super User, Laurens plays a crucial role in maintaining a knowledge sharing environment. Always ensuring a positive experience for everyone.   Leadership: He shares valuable insights on community growth, engagement, and future trends. Their contributions help shape the Power Platform Community.   Congratulations, Laurens Martens, for your outstanding work! Keep inspiring others and making a difference in the community!   Keep up the fantastic work!        

Check out the Copilot Studio Cookbook today!

We are excited to announce our new Copilot Cookbook Gallery in the Copilot Studio Community. We can't wait for you to share your expertise and your experience!    Join us for an amazing opportunity where you'll be one of the first to contribute to the Copilot Cookbook—your ultimate guide to mastering Microsoft Copilot. Whether you're seeking inspiration or grappling with a challenge while crafting apps, you probably already know that Copilot Cookbook is your reliable assistant, offering a wealth of tips and tricks at your fingertips--and we want you to add your expertise. What can you "cook" up?   Click this link to get started: https://aka.ms/CS_Copilot_Cookbook_Gallery   Don't miss out on this exclusive opportunity to be one of the first in the Community to share your app creation journey with Copilot. We'll be announcing a Cookbook Challenge very soon and want to make sure you one of the first "cooks" in the kitchen.   Don't miss your moment--start submitting in the Copilot Cookbook Gallery today!     Thank you,  Engagement Team

Announcing Power Apps Copilot Cookbook Gallery

We are excited to share that the all-new Copilot Cookbook Gallery for Power Apps is now available in the Power Apps Community, full of tips and tricks on how to best use Microsoft Copilot as you develop and create in Power Apps. The new Copilot Cookbook is your go-to resource when you need inspiration--or when you're stuck--and aren't sure how to best partner with Copilot while creating apps.   Whether you're looking for the best prompts or just want to know about responsible AI use, visit Copilot Cookbook for regular updates you can rely on--while also serving up some of your greatest tips and tricks for the Community. Check Out the new Copilot Cookbook for Power Apps today: Copilot Cookbook - Power Platform Community.  We can't wait to see what you "cook" up!      

Tuesday Tip | How to Report Spam in Our Community

It's time for another TUESDAY TIPS, your weekly connection with the most insightful tips and tricks that empower both newcomers and veterans in the Power Platform Community! Every Tuesday, we bring you a curated selection of the finest advice, distilled from the resources and tools in the Community. Whether you’re a seasoned member or just getting started, Tuesday Tips are the perfect compass guiding you across the dynamic landscape of the Power Platform Community.   As our community family expands each week, we revisit our essential tools, tips, and tricks to ensure you’re well-versed in the community’s pulse. Keep an eye on the News & Announcements for your weekly Tuesday Tips—you never know what you may learn!   Today's Tip: How to Report Spam in Our Community We strive to maintain a professional and helpful community, and part of that effort involves keeping our platform free of spam. If you encounter a post that you believe is spam, please follow these steps to report it: Locate the Post: Find the post in question within the community.Kebab Menu: Click on the "Kebab" menu | 3 Dots, on the top right of the post.Report Inappropriate Content: Select "Report Inappropriate Content" from the menu.Submit Report: Fill out any necessary details on the form and submit your report.   Our community team will review the report and take appropriate action to ensure our community remains a valuable resource for everyone.   Thank you for helping us keep the community clean and useful!

Community Roundup: A Look Back at Our Last 10 Tuesday Tips

As we continue to grow and learn together, it's important to reflect on the valuable insights we've shared. For today's #TuesdayTip, we're excited to take a moment to look back at the last 10 tips we've shared in case you missed any or want to revisit them. Thanks for your incredible support for this series--we're so glad it was able to help so many of you navigate your community experience!   Getting Started in the Community An overview of everything you need to know about navigating the community on one page!  Community Links: ○ Power Apps ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Community Ranks and YOU Have you ever wondered how your fellow community members ascend the ranks within our community? We explain everything about ranks and how to achieve points so you can climb up in the rankings! Community Links: ○ Power Apps ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Powering Up Your Community Profile Your Community User Profile is how the Community knows you--so it's essential that it works the way you need it to! From changing your username to updating contact information, this Knowledge Base Article is your best resource for powering up your profile. Community Links: ○ Power Apps ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Community Blogs--A Great Place to Start There's so much you'll discover in the Community Blogs, and we hope you'll check them out today!  Community Links: ○ Power Apps ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Unlocking Community Achievements and Earning Badges Across the Communities, you'll see badges on users profile that recognize and reward their engagement and contributions. Check out some details on Community badges--and find out more in the detailed link at the end of the article! Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Blogging in the Community Interested in blogging? Everything you need to know on writing blogs in our four communities! Get started blogging across the Power Platform communities today! Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Subscriptions & Notifications We don't want you to miss a thing in the community! Read all about how to subscribe to sections of our forums and how to setup your notifications! Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Getting Started with Private Messages & Macros Do you want to enhance your communication in the Community and streamline your interactions? One of the best ways to do this is to ensure you are using Private Messaging--and the ever-handy macros that are available to you as a Community member! Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Community User Groups Learn everything about being part of, starting, or leading a User Group in the Power Platform Community. Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Update Your Community Profile Today! Keep your community profile up to date which is essential for staying connected and engaged with the community. Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Thank you for being an integral part of our journey.   Here's to many more Tuesday Tips as we pave the way for a brighter, more connected future! As always, watch the News & Announcements for the next set of tips, coming soon!

Hear what's next for the Power Up Program

Hear from Principal Program Manager, Dimpi Gandhi, to discover the latest enhancements to the Microsoft #PowerUpProgram, including a new accelerated video-based curriculum crafted with the expertise of Microsoft MVPs, Rory Neary and Charlie Phipps-Bennett. If you’d like to hear what’s coming next, click the link below to sign up today! https://aka.ms/PowerUp  

Top Solution Authors
Top Kudoed Authors
Users online (3,402)