cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Reply
SaWu
Impactful Individual
Impactful Individual

Problems with ComboBox.OnChange triggering too often and with weird timing.

Hello

Please be so kind as to read my full post before responding.
Thank you for your consideration.

In my PowerApp I often use the pattern of having something like

UpdateContext({
    unsaved: true
})

in my input controls, and only show things like Save or Reset buttons depending on unsaved.
In my MyForm.OnReset event I have

UpdateContext({
    unsaved: false
})

and my Save and Cancel buttons both use

ResetForm(MyForm)


However, I am having trouble using this together with ComboBoxes used with LookUp fields when using Save, or when entering the Screen.
It appears that the ComboBox.OnChange event gets triggered with a "weird timing" and more often than, say, TextInput.OnChange.
Hence, whenever I enter the screen or Save anything (Save triggers ResetForm in my case), ComboBox.OnChange gets triggered.
In contrast, for example TextInput.OnChange only gets triggered with an actual text change.

As an example to better highlight my problem, I have slightly modified one of my PowerApps that uses ComboBoxes in an EditForm.
I added a text context Variable logTxt with Screen.OnVisible

UpdateContext({
    logTxt: ""
})

and changed ComboBox.OnChange to, and note the "safeguard" resetting

UpdateContext({
    logTxt: logTxt & "
ComboBox.OnChange"});
If(!resetting,
    UpdateContext({deliveryUnsaved: true})
)

all my TextInput.OnChange to

UpdateContext({
    deliveryUnsaved: true,
    logTxt: logTxt & "
TextInput.OnChange"
});

and Form.OnReset

UpdateContext({
    deliveryUnsaved: false,
    logTxt: logTxt & "
Form.OnReset"
})

I also added a big Label with Label.Text set

"logTxt:
" & logTxt

and at the end of my Cancel/ResetForm and my Save buttons I have

UpdateContext({
    resetting: true
});
ResetForm(LieferungForm);
UpdateContext({
    resetting: false
})



Using, this, upon entry to the screen, with nonempty default record selected, I already see this:
image.png

That is, by "virtue" of ComboBox.OnChange triggering, I have already entered my PowerApp Mode of having unsaved changes without actually having done anything.

Changing the Text in one TextInput yields:
image.png

Saving via SaveButton.OnSelect and thus triggering ResetForm yields:
image.png

which causes an unexpected triggering on ComboBox.OnChange after Form.OnReset ignoring the resetting safeguard and the order of functions inside my SaveButton.OnSelect event.

Trying to afterwards change the ComboBox itself triggers another ComboBox.OnChange:
image.png

Saving and triggering ResetForm again yields:
image.png

which again causes an unexpected triggering of ComboBox.OnChange after Form.OnReset ignoring the resetting safeguard and the order of functions inside my Save buttons OnSelect event.

 

My questions:

  1. How do I get this setup to work even with that ComboBox.OnChange nonsense?
  2. Why is ComboBox.OnChange triggering so often, and completely inconsistent with the way OnChange gets triggered for TextInput controls?
  3. Why is ComboBox.OnChange triggering at all from using ResetForm? No other controls seem to do this.
  4. Shouldn't Form.OnReset trigger after all controls inside the form have already been reset, i.e. shouldn't Form.OnReset be in my logs after ComboBox.OnChange?

Last tested with:

App ID: 8200a3f3-30fd-44f9-b3b7-0c9e0f803c50
Session ID: 21a66c2e-a2f6-472c-bffc-a84600ce0745
PowerApps 3.19081.26


If you have read all of this properly, thank you!
If you have a solution for me or know documented answers, thank you and kudos!
    Sa.

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
Rebetcha
Impactful Individual
Impactful Individual

Hi @SaWu ,

Apparently the Combo Box logic of OnChange is simply different than for the rest of the controls. I would post this as an idea to bring it under the attention of the Product Team. 

Regarding a work around: instead of using a variable you can do the Excel thing and compare the current value of the combo box to the ThisItem.Value of the corresponding field directly in the Visible property of for example the Save button. 

View solution in original post

14 REPLIES 14
Rebetcha
Impactful Individual
Impactful Individual

Hi @SaWu ,

Apparently the Combo Box logic of OnChange is simply different than for the rest of the controls. I would post this as an idea to bring it under the attention of the Product Team. 

Regarding a work around: instead of using a variable you can do the Excel thing and compare the current value of the combo box to the ThisItem.Value of the corresponding field directly in the Visible property of for example the Save button. 

SaWu
Impactful Individual
Impactful Individual

Hello @Rebetcha 

I have now posted this as an idea
https://powerusers.microsoft.com/t5/PowerApps-Ideas/Please-make-ComboBox-OnChange-trigger-consistent...
And kudos for the workaround idea.

Thank you,
    Sa.

Rebetcha
Impactful Individual
Impactful Individual

I voted up your idea! 🙂
9dj89
Frequent Visitor
hjaf
Kudo Commander
Kudo Commander

I believe I have encountered similar issues with combobox OnChange outside of a form as well. 

I use OnChange on a combobox to trigger a set of actions that will at some point change the collection in Items for the combobox itself when certain conditions are met. I also do some manipulation on the collection in Items, if the manipulation is removed (filter in my case) it reduced the double-triggering, however, reloading the collection still triggers the OnChange, this makes sense as clearcollect() will obviously change the selection as its temporarily unavailable. 

I'm guessing that when part of a form, the form does manipulation or calculation on the datacard-Default, perhaps to update its Unsaved property(?), this is perhaps one reason for OnChange triggering. 
In any case, the documentation states:
OnChange – How the app responds when the user changes a selection.

Possible workaround to enforce behavior only on user actions: 

Use the OnSelect property to set a context variable to true, if true the OnChange sets the variable to false before proceeding otherwise it does nothing.

james_hathaway
Advocate V
Advocate V

And just to make matters worse - the timing of the ComboBox_OnChange event is not even consistent with ITSELF!

 

Example - If you add the following code to the OnChange event of the drop-down:

Set(variable, ComboBox1.Selected)

you do NOT always get the value that the combobox was changed TO - you SOMETIMES get the value that it was set to BEFORE it was changed, making it a completely useless event to use.

 

my advice - do not put ANYTHING into a ComboBox On_Change event - it is full of Bugs, and will give you all sorts of strange App behaviour...

krishangopi
Advocate II
Advocate II

Completely agree. Even today, I found stange behaviour of OnChange in combobox control in a gallary. It is set to collect the record changed using ThisItem and my surprise, one change records some six-seven records randomly and some records repeating.

 

Couldn't believe it was a bug and kept digging at the code.

 

Regards,

Krishan

I voted up, as well, and also commented this should not be an "idea" but a "bug". Why is PowerApps triggering the onChange event when the value should ONLY change once a user interacts with the control? It makes PowerApps seem very immature when this is how onChange events in dropdown lists on websites have worked for over 20 years.

KarlInOz1
Helper II
Helper II

I voted up too & commented.

So, I got my Combobox working with these settings:

2022-03-31 13_33_13-Window.png

 

It works well. But I wish I could say the same for a Toggle control. That is a different beast and I just can't seem to get that one working. I have tried using the OnCheck and OnUncheck fields but I just can't tame the beast. I think I'm beaten on that one.

Helpful resources

Announcements

Exclusive LIVE Community Event: Power Apps Copilot Coffee Chat with Copilot Studio Product Team

  It's time for the SECOND Power Apps Copilot Coffee Chat featuring the Copilot Studio product team, which will be held LIVE on April 3, 2024 at 9:30 AM Pacific Daylight Time (PDT).     This is an incredible opportunity to connect with members of the Copilot Studio product team and ask them anything about Copilot Studio. We'll share our special guests with you shortly--but we want to encourage to mark your calendars now because you will not want to miss the conversation.   This live event will give you the unique opportunity to learn more about Copilot Studio plans, where we’ll focus, and get insight into upcoming features. We’re looking forward to hearing from the community, so bring your questions!   TO GET ACCESS TO THIS EXCLUSIVE AMA: Kudo this post to reserve your spot! Reserve your spot now by kudoing this post.  Reservations will be prioritized on when your kudo for the post comes through, so don't wait! Click that "kudo button" today.   Invitations will be sent on April 2nd.Users posting Kudos after April 2nd. at 9AM PDT may not receive an invitation but will be able to view the session online after conclusion of the event. Give your "kudo" today and mark your calendars for April 3rd, 2024 at 9:30 AM PDT and join us for an engaging and informative session!

Tuesday Tip: Unlocking Community Achievements and Earning Badges

TUESDAY TIPS are our way of communicating helpful things we've learned or shared that have helped members of the Community. Whether you're just getting started or you're a seasoned pro, Tuesday Tips will help you know where to go, what to look for, and navigate your way through the ever-growing--and ever-changing--world of the Power Platform Community! We cover basics about the Community, provide a few "insider tips" to make your experience even better, and share best practices gleaned from our most active community members and Super Users.   With so many new Community members joining us each week, we'll also review a few of our "best practices" so you know just "how" the Community works, so make sure to watch the News & Announcements each week for the latest and greatest Tuesday Tips!     THIS WEEK'S TIP: Unlocking Achievements and Earning BadgesAcross the Communities, you'll see badges on users profile that recognize and reward their engagement and contributions. These badges each signify a different achievement--and all of those achievements are available to any Community member! If you're a seasoned pro or just getting started, you too can earn badges for the great work you do. Check out some details on Community badges below--and find out more in the detailed link at the end of the article!       A Diverse Range of Badges to Collect The badges you can earn in the Community cover a wide array of activities, including: Kudos Received: Acknowledges the number of times a user’s post has been appreciated with a “Kudo.”Kudos Given: Highlights the user’s generosity in recognizing others’ contributions.Topics Created: Tracks the number of discussions initiated by a user.Solutions Provided: Celebrates the instances where a user’s response is marked as the correct solution.Reply: Counts the number of times a user has engaged with community discussions.Blog Contributor: Honors those who contribute valuable content and are invited to write for the community blog.       A Community Evolving Together Badges are not only a great way to recognize outstanding contributions of our amazing Community members--they are also a way to continue fostering a collaborative and supportive environment. As you continue to share your knowledge and assist each other these badges serve as a visual representation of your valuable contributions.   Find out more about badges in these Community Support pages in each Community: All About Community Badges - Power Apps CommunityAll About Community Badges - Power Automate CommunityAll About Community Badges - Copilot Studio CommunityAll About Community Badges - Power Pages Community

Tuesday Tips: Powering Up Your Community Profile

TUESDAY TIPS are our way of communicating helpful things we've learned or shared that have helped members of the Community. Whether you're just getting started or you're a seasoned pro, Tuesday Tips will help you know where to go, what to look for, and navigate your way through the ever-growing--and ever-changing--world of the Power Platform Community! We cover basics about the Community, provide a few "insider tips" to make your experience even better, and share best practices gleaned from our most active community members and Super Users.   With so many new Community members joining us each week, we'll also review a few of our "best practices" so you know just "how" the Community works, so make sure to watch the News & Announcements each week for the latest and greatest Tuesday Tips!   This Week's Tip: Power Up Your Profile!  🚀 It's where every Community member gets their start, and it's essential that you keep it updated! Your Community User Profile is how you're able to get messages, post solutions, ask questions--and as you rank up, it's where your badges will appear and how you'll be known when you start blogging in the Community Blog. Your Community User Profile is how the Community knows you--so it's essential that it works the way you need it to! From changing your username to updating contact information, this Knowledge Base Article is your best resource for powering up your profile.     Password Puzzles? No Problem! Find out how to sync your Azure AD password with your community account, ensuring a seamless sign-in. No separate passwords to remember! Job Jumps & Email Swaps Changed jobs? Got a new email? Fear not! You'll find out how to link your shiny new email to your existing community account, keeping your contributions and connections intact. Username Uncertainties Unraveled Picking the perfect username is crucial--and sometimes the original choice you signed up with doesn't fit as well as you may have thought. There's a quick way to request an update here--but remember, your username is your community identity, so choose wisely. "Need Admin Approval" Warning Window? If you see this error message while using the community, don't worry. A simple process will help you get where you need to go. If you still need assistance, find out how to contact your Community Support team. Whatever you're looking for, when it comes to your profile, the Community Account Support Knowledge Base article is your treasure trove of tips as you navigate the nuances of your Community Profile. It’s the ultimate resource for keeping your digital identity in tip-top shape while engaging with the Power Platform Community. So, dive in and power up your profile today!  💪🚀   Community Account Support | Power Apps Community Account Support | Power AutomateCommunity Account Support | Copilot Studio  Community Account Support | Power Pages

Super User of the Month | Chris Piasecki

In our 2nd installment of this new ongoing feature in the Community, we're thrilled to announce that Chris Piasecki is our Super User of the Month for March 2024. If you've been in the Community for a while, we're sure you've seen a comment or marked one of Chris' helpful tips as a solution--he's been a Super User for SEVEN consecutive seasons!       Since authoring his first reply in April 2020 to his most recent achievement organizing the Canadian Power Platform Summit this month, Chris has helped countless Community members with his insights and expertise. In addition to being a Super User, Chris is also a User Group leader, Microsoft MVP, and a featured speaker at the Microsoft Power Platform Conference. His contributions to the new SUIT program, along with his joyous personality and willingness to jump in and help so many members has made Chris a fixture in the Power Platform Community.   When Chris isn't authoring solutions or organizing events, he's actively leading Piasecki Consulting, specializing in solution architecture, integration, DevOps, and more--helping clients discover how to strategize and implement Microsoft's technology platforms. We are grateful for Chris' insightful help in the Community and look forward to even more amazing milestones as he continues to assist so many with his great tips, solutions--always with a smile and a great sense of humor.You can find Chris in the Community and on LinkedIn. Thanks for being such a SUPER user, Chris! 💪🌠

Tuesday Tips: Community Ranks and YOU

TUESDAY TIPS are our way of communicating helpful things we've learned or shared that have helped members of the Community. Whether you're just getting started or you're a seasoned pro, Tuesday Tips will help you know where to go, what to look for, and navigate your way through the ever-growing--and ever-changing--world of the Power Platform Community! We cover basics about the Community, provide a few "insider tips" to make your experience even better, and share best practices gleaned from our most active community members and Super Users.   With so many new Community members joining us each week, we'll also review a few of our "best practices" so you know just "how" the Community works, so make sure to watch the News & Announcements each week for the latest and greatest Tuesday Tips!This Week: Community Ranks--Moving from "Member" to "Community Champion"   Have you ever wondered how your fellow community members ascend the ranks within our community? What sets apart an Advocate from a Helper, or a Solution Sage from a Community Champion? In today’s #TuesdayTip, we’re unveiling the secrets and sharing tips to help YOU elevate your ranking—and why it matters to our vibrant communities. Community ranks serve as a window into a member’s role and activity. They celebrate your accomplishments and reveal whether someone has been actively contributing and assisting others. For instance, a Super User is someone who has been exceptionally helpful and engaged. Some ranks even come with special permissions, especially those related to community management. As you actively participate—whether by creating new topics, providing solutions, or earning kudos—your rank can climb. Each time you achieve a new rank, you’ll receive an email notification. Look out for the icon and rank name displayed next to your username—it’s a badge of honor! Fun fact: Your Community Engagement Team keeps an eye on these ranks, recognizing the most passionate and active community members. So shine brightly with valuable content, and you might just earn well-deserved recognition! Where can you see someone’s rank? When viewing a post, you’ll find a member’s rank to the left of their name.Click on a username to explore their profile, where their rank is prominently displayed. What about the ranks themselves? New members start as New Members, progressing to Regular Visitors, and then Frequent Visitors.Beyond that, we have a categorized system: Kudo Ranks: Earned through kudos (teal icons).Post Ranks: Based on your posts (purple icons).Solution Ranks: Reflecting your solutions (green icons).Combo Ranks: These orange icons combine kudos, solutions, and posts. The top ranks have unique names, making your journey even more exciting! So dive in, collect those kudos, share solutions, and let’s see how high you can rank! 🌟 🚀   Check out the Using the Community boards in each of the communities for more helpful information!  Power Apps, Power Automate, Copilot Studio & Power Pages

Find Out What Makes Super Users So Super

We know many of you visit the Power Platform Communities to ask questions and receive answers. But do you know that many of our best answers and solutions come from Community members who are super active, helping anyone who needs a little help getting unstuck with Business Applications products? We call these dedicated Community members Super Users because they are the real heroes in the Community, willing to jump in whenever they can to help! Maybe you've encountered them yourself and they've solved some of your biggest questions. Have you ever wondered, "Why?"We interviewed several of our Super Users to understand what drives them to help in the Community--and discover the difference it has made in their lives as well! Take a look in our gallery today: What Motivates a Super User? - Power Platform Community (microsoft.com)

Top Solution Authors
Top Kudoed Authors
Users online (5,746)