cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Reply
RusselThomas
Community Champion
Community Champion

Why with, why?

This is likely to be an advanced question, but I am curious to see if any of the community or MS members can answer this one.  it has me stumped to the point I suspect it may even be a bug - but I'm always willing to be corrected and learn something new, so...

 

If you consider the If statement construct as follows;

 

If(boolean condition, instruction when condition = true, instruction when condition = false)

 

You can, if you like, have two completely different instructions for when the condition is true, and when it is false, each with completely different outputs.  By this I mean you can have something like this;

 

If(a=b, 
    Collect(myCollection, {Value: "something"}), 
    Launch("www.bing.com"))
)

 

Pretty much any instruction you give PowerApps has an output of some sort, whether you can see it or not.

  • When you Collect(), it outputs a table.
  • When you Launch(), it outputs a boolean value (for those who are curious, this returns True when the Launch function runs properly).
  • and so on...

The above example works perfectly fine if you place it on a button or other behaviour property.

However, if you place that exact same If() function inside a With() function, there is a constraint placed on the If instruction set that requires their outputs to be the same.  In other words, if the first instruction (instruction when condition = true) results in a table, then the second instruction (instruction when condition = false) must also result in a table, otherwise you get a type mismatch error which, for the example above would be "expecting a table".  To illustrate with a slightly different example;

 

With({something: "Something"},
If(a=b, 
    Today(), 
    Launch("www.google.com"))
)

 

This will present an error under the Launch() function saying it expects a date output - because the first instruction results in a date.

Go ahead and check it out yourself - If anyone understands why this is the case, or has a different experience, I'd love to hear from you!

Kind regards,

RT

4 REPLIES 4
TheRobRush
Super User
Super User

Works just fine for me using this context

With({a: "hello",
    b: "hdllo"},
If(a=b, 
    Set(DateNow,Today()), 
    Launch("www.google.com"))
)

 

typing it like above, launched google. changing both hellos to match, set a variable for my date

 

But when I cheanged first portion from a set, to a Collect() then it behaved as you said. Tried a little further by switchting the collect to a loookup and it gave expecting a record. Looks like it may be very specifically limited when tables are used / including records. Maybe a bug.

 

@WarrenBelz @RandyHayes Do either of you know if this behavior is intended or perhaps behaving more liek a bug?

_____________________________________________________________________________________
Like my answer? - Hit that Thumbs Up. Resolved the Issue? - Hit Accept as Solution.
This helps others find solutions to future issues!
JesseV
Advocate I
Advocate I

I attempted the following in 'OnSelect'  of a label 

 

With({something: "Something"};
If( 1 = 2 ;  
    Text(Today()); 
    Launch("www.google.com"))
)

 

And it worked fine. I'm still very new in PowerApps but what usually happens to me when bugfixing is that I did silly things in completely other areas of the script.

 

It's not something with the 

a=b

variables ? 

timl
Super User
Super User

Hi @RusselThomas 

Thanks for raising this issue.

I would like for this behaviour to be acknowledged and treated as a bug by Microsoft. It doesn't make sense why a call to If should behave differently when inside With, and the documention makes no reference to the If function not supporting different return values in the true and false branches.

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-gb/power-platform/power-fx/reference/function-if

 

This behaviour causes much confusion and I've answered a few posts on this topic, such as the one below. Here, you can see how this behaviour also applies to Concurrent, and also the hack I use to return a boolean on both branches of the call to If.

https://powerusers.microsoft.com/t5/Building-Power-Apps/Strange-behaviour-of-Concurrent-function-and...

 

 

RusselThomas
Community Champion
Community Champion

Thanks @timl , @TheRobRush and @JesseV  for testing and responding.

Interesting to see similar behaviour in Concurrent().  Nesting If()'s doesn't have the same effect so I guess it's something to do with the if statement itself and how it behaves within other functions - perhaps some scoping type constraint weirdness? 

I tried Switch and it worked fine....

 

By the way, it's not just tables that have this issue - the following also does not work;

 

With({something: "Something"},
If(1=2, 
    Today(), //Date output
    Launch("www.bing.com") //boolean output
    )
)

 

 

And if you tested and didn't see the error, you were most likely wrapping a function with one type of output inside another function with another type of output - which just means the outer function type is evaluated instead of the inner, so yes, you can work around this problem by matching the outputs of outer functions to previous true statements, like the following - which works fine;

With({something: "Something"},
If(
    1=2, Collect(myCollection, {Value: "something"}), //Collect() has a table output
    2=3, FirstN(ComboBoxSample,2),                    //FirstN() has a table output
    3=4, Filter(ComboBoxSample, Value1="something"),  //Filter has a table output
    
    //with the boolean output wrapped inside a table output
    Collect(collectSomething, Launch("www.bing.com")) 
    )
)

This will not throw any errors - likewise you can do the inverse, i.e. matching the true statement output to the false statement output by wrapping it;

With({something: "Something"},
If(1=2, 
    Set(myVar, Collect(myCollection, {Value: "something"})), //Set() has a boolean output
    Launch("www.bing.com")                                   //Launch() has boolean output
    )
)

but working around it isn't really the idea I'm looking for... I'm just trying to understand why the following doesn't work, when it seems logical that it should...

With({something: "Something"},
If(
    1=2, Collect(myCollection, {Value: "something"}), //table output
    2=3, Launch("www.bing.com")                       //boolean output
    3=4, Today()                                      //date output
  )
)

I guess at this point I'm leaning towards 'unwanted behaviour', so I'm still curious if anyone else picks up on this from the product team. 

Thanks again for your feedback!

Kind regards,

RT 

Helpful resources

Announcements

Check Out the February 2024 Dynamics 365 Newsletter

Some of our most active Power Platform Community members are also active in our D365 Community. This month, we are excited to share the latest news from the D365 Community with you.   Our Dynamics365 Community has updated yet again! Since launching in June of 2023, the new Community has seen consistent updates and exciting new ways to feature and celebrate its members. In the latest edition of the Dynamics365 Community newsletter, you can see the new Leaderboard feature! This feature showcases which Community members have earned the most points over the previous month, enabling them to see how they are doing with their engagement--and their progress toward Super User status. Visit the leaderboard for yourself: https://aka.ms/d365clb     Read the whole newsletter featuring the new leaderboard as well as the D365 Monthly Community Member spotlight, FastTrack Tech Talks, upcoming events, and more. February 2024 Dynamics 365 Community Newsletter

Celebrating a New Season of Super Users with Charles Lamanna, CVP Microsoft Business Applications

February 8 was the kickoff to the 2024 Season One Super User program for Power Platform Communities, and we are thrilled to welcome back so many returning Super Users--as well as so many brand new Super Users who started their journey last fall. Our Community Super Users are the true heroes, answering questions, providing solutions, filtering spam, and so much more. The impact they make on the Communities each day is significant, and we wanted to do something special to welcome them at our first kickoff meeting of the year.   Charles Lamanna, Microsoft CVP of Business Applications, has stressed frequently how valuable our Community is to the growth and potential of Power Platform, and we are honored to share this message from him to our 2024 Season One Super Users--as well as anyone who might be interested in joining this elite group of Community members.     If you want to know more about Super Users, check out these posts for more information today:    Power Apps: What is A Super User? - Power Platform CommunityPower Automate: What is A Super User? - Power Platform Community Copilot Studio: What is A Super User? - Power Platform Community Power Pages: What is A Super User? - Power Platform Community

February 2024 User Group Update: Welcoming New Groups and Highlighting Upcoming Events

It's a new month and a brand-new year, which means another opportunity to celebrate our amazing User Groups!Each month, we highlight the new User Groups that have joined the community. It's been a busy season for new groups, because we are thrilled to welcome 15 New User Groups! Take a look at the list below, shared by the different community categories. If your group is listed here, give this post a kudo so we can celebrate with you!   We love our User Groups and the difference they make in the lives of our Community! Thank you to all the new User Groups, new User Group leaders--we look forward to hearing about your successes and the impact you will leave!   In addition to our monthly New User Group spotlight, it's a great time to share some of the latest events happening in our User Group community! Take a look at the list below to find one that fits your schedule and need! There's a great combination of in-person and virtual events to choose from. It's a great time of year to connect and engage with User Groups both locally and online. Please Welcome Our NEW User Groups   Power Platform: Heathcare Power Platform User Group Power Platform Connect Hub Power Platform Usergroup Denmark Mexico Norte- Power Platform User Group Pune Power User Group Sudbury Power Platform User GroupMicrosoft User Group GhanaMPPBLR - Microsoft Power Platform Bengaluru User Group Power Apps:   Myrtle Beach Power Platform User GroupAnanseTechWB PowerApps Copilot Studio: Pathfinders Power Platform Community Dynamics365: Cairo, Egypt MSD 365 Business Central/NAV/F&O User GruopMS Dynamics 365 Business Central LatamCincinnati OH D365 F&O User Group February User Group Events February 2024 Cleveland Power Platform User GroupPortallunsj - Februar 2024Indiana D365/AX February User Group MeetingQ1 2024 KC Power Platform and Dynamics 365 CRM Users Group 

Super Users 2024 Season One is Here!

   We are excited to announce the first season of our 2024 Super Users is here! Our kickoff to the new year welcomes many returning Super Users and several new faces, and it's always exciting to see the impact these incredible individuals will have on the Community in 2024! We are so grateful for the daily difference they make in the Community already and know they will keep staying engaged and excited for all that will happen this year.   How to Spot a Super User in the Community:Have you ever written a post or asked for help in the Community and had it answered by a user with the Super User icon next to their name? It means you have found the actual, real-life superheroes of the Power Platform Community! Super Users are our heroes because of the way they consistently make a difference in the Community. Our amazing Super Users help keep the Community a safe place by flagging spam and letting the Community Managers know about issues. They also make the Community a great place to find answers, because they are often the first to offer solutions and get clarity on questions. Finally, Super Users share valuable insights on ways to keep the Community growing, engaging, and looking ahead!We are honored to reveal the new badges for this season of Super Users! Congratulations to all the new and returning Super Users!     To better answer the question "What is a Super User?" please check out this article: Power Apps: What is A Super User? - Power Platform CommunityPower Automate: What is A Super User? - Power Platform Community Copilot Studio: What is A Super User? - Power Platform Community Power Pages: What is A Super User? - Power Platform Community

January 2024 Community Newsletter

Welcome to our January Newsletter, where we highlight the latest news, product releases, upcoming events, and the amazing work of our outstanding Community members. If you're new to the Community, please make sure to follow the latest News & Announcements in each Community and check out the Community on LinkedIn as well! It's the best way to stay up-to-date in 2024 with all the news from across Microsoft Power Platform and beyond.      COMMUNITY HIGHLIGHTS Check out the most active community members of the last month! These hardworking members are posting regularly, answering questions, giving (and receiving!) kudos, and consistently providing top solutions in their communities. We are so thankful for each of you--keep up the great work! If you hope to see your name here next month, make it your New Year's Resolution to be more active in the community in 2024.   Power AppsPower AutomateCopilot StudioPower PagesWarrenBelzWarrenBelzPstork1saudali_25LaurensMPstork1stephenrobertLucas001AARON_ClbendincpaytonSurendran_RANBNived_NambiarMariamPaulachanNikhil2JmanriqueriosANBJupyter123rodger-stmmbr1606Agniusstevesmith27mandelaPhineastrice602AnnaMoyalanOOlashynBCLS776grantjenkinsExpiscornovusJcookSpongYeAARON_CManishSolankiapangelesPstork1ManishSolankiSanju1Fubar   LATEST NEWS Power Platform 2024 Release Wave Highlights This month saw the 2024 Release Wave 1 plans for Microsoft Power Platform and Microsoft Dynamics 365- a compilation of new capabilities planned for release between April and September 2024. Click here to read Corporate Vice President Maureen (Mo) Osborne's detailed breakdown of the upcoming capabilities, and click the image below to check out some of the Power Platform 2024 Release Wave 1 highlights.     "What's New" Power Platform Shorts Series This month we also launched our brand-new 'Power Shorts' series on YouTube - a selection of super sweet snapshots to keep you in the loop with all the latest trends from across the Power Platform and beyond. Click the image below to check out the entire playlist so far, and don't forget to subscribe to our YouTube channel for all the latest updates.   Super User In Training (S.U.I.T) It was great to see the Power Platform Community officially kick off Season One of their Super User in Training (SUIT) program this month! Their first meeting saw an amazing turnout of over 300 enthusiastic participants who started their dynamic journey toward becoming Super Users. Huge thanks to Manas Maheshwari, Eric Archer, Heather Hernandez, and Duane Montague for a fantastic kick-off. The first meeting also saw seasoned Super User, Drew Poggemann, share invaluable insights on navigating the #MicrosoftCommunity with finesse. Many thanks to Drew for setting the stage and emphasizing the importance of active engagement and the art of providing thoughtful community solutions. If you want to learn more about the features and benefits of gaining Super User status, click the image below to find out more, and watch this space for more info about Season Two and how you can SUIT UP in the community!     UPCOMING EVENTS Microsoft 365 Community Day - Miami - February 1-2, 2024 It's not long now until the Microsoft 365 Community Day Miami, which will be taking place at the Wolfson Campus at Miami Dade College on 1-2 Feb. 2024. This free event is all about unlocking the full potential of Power Platform, Microsoft 365, and AI, so whether you’re a tech enthusiast, a business owner, or just curious about the latest Microsoft advancements, #M365Miami is for you.   The event is completely free and there will sessions in both English and Spanish to celebrate the vibrant and diverse make-up of our amazing community. Click the image below to join this amazing Community Day in Miami and become a part of our incredible network of learners and innovators!     Microsoft Fabric - Las Vegas - March 26-28, 2024 Exciting times ahead for the inaugural #MicrosoftFabric Community Conference on March 26-28 at the MGM Grand in Las Vegas. And if you book now, you can save $100 off registration! The Microsoft Fabric Conference will cover all the latest in analytics, AI, databases, and governance across 150+ sessions.   There will be a special Community Lounge onsite, interactive learning labs, plus you'll be able to 'Ask the Experts' all your questions to get help from data, analytics, and AI specialists, including community members and the Fabric Customer Advisory Team. Just add the code MSCUST when registering for a $100 discount today. Click the image below to find out more about the ultimate learning event for Microsoft Fabric!     Microsoft 365 Conference - Orlando - April 30 - May 2, 2024 Have you added The Microsoft 365 Conference to your community calendar yet? It happens this April 30th - May 2nd in Orlando, Florida. The 2024 Microsoft 365 Conference is one of the world’s largest gatherings of Microsoft engineers and community, with a strong focus on Power Platform, SharePoint, Azure, and the transition to an AI-powered modern workplace.   Click the image link below to find out more and be prepared to be enlightened, educated, and inspired at #M365Conf24!   LATEST COMMUNITY BLOG ARTICLES Power Apps Community Blog Power Automate Community Blog Copilot Studio Community Blog Power Pages Community Blog Check out 'Using the Community' for more helpful tips and information: Power Apps, Power Automate, Copilot Studio, Power Pages  

Did You Attend the Microsoft Power Platform Conference in 2022 or 2023? Claim Your Badge Today!

If you were one of the thousands of people who joined us at the first #MPPC Microsoft Power Platform Conference in 2022 in Orlando--or attended the second-annual conference in Las Vegas in 2023--we are excited to honor you with a special community badge! Show your support for #MPPC Microsoft Power Platform Conference this year by claiming your badge!         Just follow this link to claim your badge for attending #MPPC in 2022 and/or 2023: MPPCBadgeRequest    Want to earn your badge for 2024? Just keep watching our News & Announcements for the latest updates on #MPPC24.

Top Solution Authors
Top Kudoed Authors
Users online (2,771)