cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Reply
Anonymous
Not applicable

Combo Boxes Depend on each other/Circural Reference

Good day, 

I am trying on combo boxes selections depend on all other combo boxes.

For example, 5 combo boxes: A,B, C ,D, E. Let's say we select combo box in the sequence below:

1. ComboBoxC
2. ComboBoxB

3. ComboBoxD

So the selection of B is depends on C, the selection of D is depends on C and B.

For the combo box is not selected, it should show whole table.

Each Combo Box OnChange property = 

Set(VariableName, ComboBox.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

Each Combo Box Item property =

Filter
(
TableName,
IF(isEmpty(ComboBoxA), true, VariableNameA in ColumnA),
IF(isEmpty(ComboBoxB), true, VariableNameB in ColumnB),
.
.
.
)

In some Item Property, I use "ComboBox.SelectedItems" and some I use VariableName, because I got the error of circular reference.

Although it doesn't show any error, but all combo boxes are empty selections now.

Any idea on making all combo boxes able to depend on each other?

Thank you so much!

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
v-xida-msft
Community Support
Community Support

Hi @Anonymous ,

Could you please share a bit more about your scenario?

Do you want each ComboBox to be dependent on other 4 ComboBoxes in your app?

Further, could you please show more details about the 'Circural Reference' error within your app?

 

Based on the formula you provided, I think there is something wrong with it. I have made a test on my side, please take a try with the following workaround:

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxA to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxACol, ComboBoxA.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxB to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxBCol, ComboBoxB.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxC to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxCCol, ComboBoxC.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxD to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxDCol, ComboBoxD.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxE to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxECol, ComboBoxE.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

 

Set the Items property of above each ComboBox to following:

Filter(
       TableName,
       If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxACol), true, ColumnA in ComboBoxACol),              /* <-- Type  ColumnA in ComboBoxACol rather than  ComboBoxACol in ColumnA */
       If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxBCol), true, ColumnB in ComboBoxBCol),
If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxCCol), true, ColumnC in ComboBoxCCol),
If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxDCol), true, ColumnD in ComboBoxDCol),
If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxECol), true, ColumnE in ComboBoxECol) )

Please take a try with above solution, then check if the issue is solved.

 

Best regards,

Community Support Team _ Kris Dai
If this post helps, then please consider Accept it as the solution to help the other members find it more quickly.

View solution in original post

3 REPLIES 3
RusselThomas
Community Champion
Community Champion

Hi @Anonymous ,

Firstly, let me say that I wish we had an updated Gallery or Data Grid Control that supported dynamically nested filter columns.

Creating one manually is quite literally a massive pain and, for some use cases - just plain impossible.

If I'm right, you're asking for any multiple combinations of multiple filters to ultimately filter a Gallery result.  This is an exercise in dynamic exponential logic, so be prepared a) for long and nested Filter functions and potentially b) a slow app.

Consider this:

  • The Filter() function processes each logical test using the AND logical function - meaning ALL the tests must be true for a record before it is displayed.  If, for example, your second combo selection is empty and the first is not, only those records that have the first combo column value AND an empty second column value would match.
  • To avoid this, you have to nest your filters - so the second Filter check is done against the result of the first Filter.  Here, you get locked into the order in which you evalute each them, which is not ideal from a user experience perspective.
  • To avoid that, you need to have a user-selected order to evaluate against - and to do that, you need to record the order in which the user selects their filters and then execute those filters in that order - which just adds more complexity and pain.
  • The only way (I know of anyway) to achieve this with any degree of success is to statically tie filter buttons to create entries in a collection for their specific filter against an indexed order of filters.  Would be very happy for someone to correct me here.
  • Your actual Gallery filter result then would have to statically check each filter entry in the dynamic filter list against every single column in the full data set to figure out which column you're trying to filter, and then apply the filter to that.
  • The end result is a very, very long and cumbersome formula which is massively painful to maintain - against which I usually ask myself - does the user really need this functionality, or can I present the data in a better way? - and the answer here is usually "No" and "Yes" respectively.

Add to that, every column you add as a potential filter exponentially increases your formula code as it needs to include all previous filters - so there's that.

Maye someone else has a better approach  - but now that I've hopefully convinced you not to do this - here's how I would do it -  Man LOL

  1. Limit number of concurrent active filters (let's say three in this instance) - that way you're only ever trying to figure out if a filter has been applied to one, two or three of these columns - you can exceed this if you're brave, but you'll run out of formula space eventually.  You can consider collecting each filter result into a separate collection to go full hog - but eugh.
  2. Collect the user selected filters into a collection called collectFilters.
  3. Dynamically filter the output Gallery by 1, 2 or 3 filters respectively - in any combination of filter, but in the specific order they occur in collectFilters.

The full data set is in myTable as follows;

combofilters.PNG

The order of the columns doesn't matter, just the highlighted ones will be filtered in whichever order the user creates their filters.  The order of the filters the user chooses will be stored in collectFilters and looks like this;

combofilters1.PNG

  • The filterColumn is a text reference to the column name we'll use to test and get the actual column object.
  • The filterStrings are the selected values to filter from that specific combobox
  • The filterIndex is the order in which the filter was selected by the user.

Combo Box 1 filters "Column1" of the data.  Create the first ComboBox and call it ComboFilterColumn1 - Set Items: to the data source (in this case, myTable) and the DisplayFields: and SearchFields: properties to ["Column1"], then set it's OnChange: property to 

If(!IsEmpty(ComboFilterColumn1.SelectedItems), //if this combobox is empty, just remove all entries related to it from the collection - if not.......
    If(
        IsEmpty(Filter(collectFilters, filterColumn="Column1")), //if there is currently no line for this combobox in the collection, add it
        Collect(collectFilters, {
            filterColumn: "Column1", 
            filterStrings: Concat(ComboFilterColumn1.SelectedItems, Column1, ";"), 
            filterIndex: Last(SortByColumns(collectFilters, "filterIndex", Ascending)).filterIndex + 1
            }),
        Patch(collectFilters, LookUp(collectFilters, filterColumn="Column1"), { //if there is a line for this combobox, then patch it
            filterStrings: Concat(ComboFilterColumn1.SelectedItems, Column1, ";") 
            })
    ),
    RemoveIf(collectFilters, filterColumn="Column1")
)    

 

Seems easy enough - except you need to do this for three comboboxes, so go ahead and add another two, call them ComboFilterColumn2 and ComboFilterColumn3 respectively and update their items to myTable and DisplayFields and SearchFields to their respective columns and set their Onchange: properties accordingly.

ComboFilterColumn2 Items: myTable

ComboFilterColumn2 DisplayFields & SearchFields: ["Column2"]

ComboFilterColumn2 Onchange:

If(!IsEmpty(ComboFilterColumn2.SelectedItems),
    If(
        IsEmpty(Filter(collectFilters, filterColumn="Column2")),
        Collect(collectFilters, {
            filterColumn: "Column2", 
            filterStrings: Concat(ComboFilterColumn2.SelectedItems, Column2, ";"), 
            filterIndex: Last(SortByColumns(collectFilters, "filterIndex", Ascending)).filterIndex + 1
            }),
        Patch(collectFilters, LookUp(collectFilters, filterColumn="Column2"), {
            filterStrings: Concat(ComboFilterColumn2.SelectedItems, Column2, ";") 
            })
    ),
    RemoveIf(collectFilters, filterColumn="Column2")
)

ComboFilterColumn3 Items: myTable

ComboFilterColumn3 DisplayFields & SearchFields: ["Column3"]

ComboFilterColumn3 OnChange:

If(!IsEmpty(ComboFilterColumn3.SelectedItems),
    If(
        IsEmpty(Filter(collectFilters, filterColumn="Column3")),
        Collect(collectFilters, {
            filterColumn: "Column3", 
            filterStrings: Concat(ComboFilterColumn3.SelectedItems, Column3, ";"), 
            filterIndex: Last(SortByColumns(collectFilters, "filterIndex", Ascending)).filterIndex + 1
            }),
        Patch(collectFilters, LookUp(collectFilters, filterColumn="Column3"), {
            filterStrings: Concat(ComboFilterColumn3.SelectedItems, Column3, ";") 
            })
    ),
    RemoveIf(collectFilters, filterColumn="Column3")
)   

If you're still with me and haven't jumped out the window yet - this should have set up your filter collection.  If you like, you can pop a gallery onto your page and set it's items to collectFilters and see how it behaves when you add and remove filters.

If you thought this was painful, wait until you see the Gallery Items filter function.

Add your Gallery, set it's Items: property to;

If(!IsEmpty(collectFilters),
    Switch(CountRows(collectFilters),
    1, 
        Filter(myTable,
            Switch(
                First(collectFilters).filterColumn,
                    "Column1", Column1,
                    "Column2", Column2,
                    "Column3", Column3
            ) in Split(First(collectFilters).filterStrings, ";").Result),
    2, 
        Filter(
            Filter(myTable,
            Switch(
                First(collectFilters).filterColumn,
                    "Column1", Column1,
                    "Column2", Column2,
                    "Column3", Column3
            ) in Split(First(collectFilters).filterStrings, ";").Result), 
            Switch(
                Last(collectFilters).filterColumn,
                    "Column1", Column1,
                    "Column2", Column2,
                    "Column3", Column3
            ) in Split(Last(collectFilters).filterStrings, ";").Result),
    3, 
        Filter(
            Filter(
                Filter(myTable,
                Switch(
                    First(collectFilters).filterColumn,
                        "Column1", Column1,
                        "Column2", Column2,
                        "Column3", Column3
                ) in Split(First(collectFilters).filterStrings, ";").Result), 
                Switch(
                    Last(FirstN(collectFilters, 2)).filterColumn,
                        "Column1", Column1,
                        "Column2", Column2,
                        "Column3", Column3
                ) in Split(Last(FirstN(collectFilters, 2)).filterStrings, ";").Result),
        Switch(
                Last(collectFilters).filterColumn,
                    "Column1", Column1,
                    "Column2", Column2,
                    "Column3", Column3
            ) in Split(Last(collectFilters).filterStrings, ";").Result)
    )
            
        , myTable)

Three is also a handy limit for detecting how many filters to test for - using First() for 1, Last() for 2 and Last(FirstN,2) to pick up the middle one.  You can add more combinations to pick up more, but hopefully you've already decided to go another route, or just limit the filters to three.

As I said, each additional iteration of a filter column will exponentially increase this formula;

  • 2 includes 1. 
  • 3 includes 2 & 1. 
  • 4 will include 3, 2 & 1. 
  • 5 will include 4, 3, 2 & 1

so unless you start collecting the results into separate collections and filtering those, you'll run out of formula space pretty soon.

Hope this helps,

RT

v-xida-msft
Community Support
Community Support

Hi @Anonymous ,

Could you please share a bit more about your scenario?

Do you want each ComboBox to be dependent on other 4 ComboBoxes in your app?

Further, could you please show more details about the 'Circural Reference' error within your app?

 

Based on the formula you provided, I think there is something wrong with it. I have made a test on my side, please take a try with the following workaround:

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxA to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxACol, ComboBoxA.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxB to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxBCol, ComboBoxB.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxC to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxCCol, ComboBoxC.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxD to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxDCol, ComboBoxD.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxE to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxECol, ComboBoxE.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

 

Set the Items property of above each ComboBox to following:

Filter(
       TableName,
       If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxACol), true, ColumnA in ComboBoxACol),              /* <-- Type  ColumnA in ComboBoxACol rather than  ComboBoxACol in ColumnA */
       If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxBCol), true, ColumnB in ComboBoxBCol),
If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxCCol), true, ColumnC in ComboBoxCCol),
If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxDCol), true, ColumnD in ComboBoxDCol),
If(IsEmpty(ComboBoxECol), true, ColumnE in ComboBoxECol) )

Please take a try with above solution, then check if the issue is solved.

 

Best regards,

Community Support Team _ Kris Dai
If this post helps, then please consider Accept it as the solution to help the other members find it more quickly.
Anonymous
Not applicable

@RusselThomas 

Thanks a lot on your idea, explaination and steps with guidances in detailed. I believe you are strong on PowerApps coding!

I found that I did some mistakes in my formula, so I referred to the answer from @v-xida-msft above and made the corrections. I managed to get the result I want now.

It should have similar result with your idea. It doesn't record the sequence of selected combo boxes but it can be selected without recording. It's my pleasure to read your ideas and coding. I learnt something! Thank you very much!

 

@v-xida-msft 

Thank you for your answer! I change Set() to ClearCollect() and some modification, it works now!

Except the below:

Set the OnChange property of the ComboBoxA to following:

ClearCollect(ComboBoxACol, ComboBoxA.SelectedItems.ColumnName)

I didn't write ".ColumnName", only add this part into the combo box Item property. Appreciate if you can advise which one is more efficient.

Thanks a lot!

Helpful resources

Announcements

Exclusive LIVE Community Event: Power Apps Copilot Coffee Chat with Copilot Studio Product Team

  It's time for the SECOND Power Apps Copilot Coffee Chat featuring the Copilot Studio product team, which will be held LIVE on April 3, 2024 at 9:30 AM Pacific Daylight Time (PDT).     This is an incredible opportunity to connect with members of the Copilot Studio product team and ask them anything about Copilot Studio. We'll share our special guests with you shortly--but we want to encourage to mark your calendars now because you will not want to miss the conversation.   This live event will give you the unique opportunity to learn more about Copilot Studio plans, where we’ll focus, and get insight into upcoming features. We’re looking forward to hearing from the community, so bring your questions!   TO GET ACCESS TO THIS EXCLUSIVE AMA: Kudo this post to reserve your spot! Reserve your spot now by kudoing this post.  Reservations will be prioritized on when your kudo for the post comes through, so don't wait! Click that "kudo button" today.   Invitations will be sent on April 2nd.Users posting Kudos after April 2nd. at 9AM PDT may not receive an invitation but will be able to view the session online after conclusion of the event. Give your "kudo" today and mark your calendars for April 3rd, 2024 at 9:30 AM PDT and join us for an engaging and informative session!

Tuesday Tip: Unlocking Community Achievements and Earning Badges

TUESDAY TIPS are our way of communicating helpful things we've learned or shared that have helped members of the Community. Whether you're just getting started or you're a seasoned pro, Tuesday Tips will help you know where to go, what to look for, and navigate your way through the ever-growing--and ever-changing--world of the Power Platform Community! We cover basics about the Community, provide a few "insider tips" to make your experience even better, and share best practices gleaned from our most active community members and Super Users.   With so many new Community members joining us each week, we'll also review a few of our "best practices" so you know just "how" the Community works, so make sure to watch the News & Announcements each week for the latest and greatest Tuesday Tips!     THIS WEEK'S TIP: Unlocking Achievements and Earning BadgesAcross the Communities, you'll see badges on users profile that recognize and reward their engagement and contributions. These badges each signify a different achievement--and all of those achievements are available to any Community member! If you're a seasoned pro or just getting started, you too can earn badges for the great work you do. Check out some details on Community badges below--and find out more in the detailed link at the end of the article!       A Diverse Range of Badges to Collect The badges you can earn in the Community cover a wide array of activities, including: Kudos Received: Acknowledges the number of times a user’s post has been appreciated with a “Kudo.”Kudos Given: Highlights the user’s generosity in recognizing others’ contributions.Topics Created: Tracks the number of discussions initiated by a user.Solutions Provided: Celebrates the instances where a user’s response is marked as the correct solution.Reply: Counts the number of times a user has engaged with community discussions.Blog Contributor: Honors those who contribute valuable content and are invited to write for the community blog.       A Community Evolving Together Badges are not only a great way to recognize outstanding contributions of our amazing Community members--they are also a way to continue fostering a collaborative and supportive environment. As you continue to share your knowledge and assist each other these badges serve as a visual representation of your valuable contributions.   Find out more about badges in these Community Support pages in each Community: All About Community Badges - Power Apps CommunityAll About Community Badges - Power Automate CommunityAll About Community Badges - Copilot Studio CommunityAll About Community Badges - Power Pages Community

Tuesday Tips: Powering Up Your Community Profile

TUESDAY TIPS are our way of communicating helpful things we've learned or shared that have helped members of the Community. Whether you're just getting started or you're a seasoned pro, Tuesday Tips will help you know where to go, what to look for, and navigate your way through the ever-growing--and ever-changing--world of the Power Platform Community! We cover basics about the Community, provide a few "insider tips" to make your experience even better, and share best practices gleaned from our most active community members and Super Users.   With so many new Community members joining us each week, we'll also review a few of our "best practices" so you know just "how" the Community works, so make sure to watch the News & Announcements each week for the latest and greatest Tuesday Tips!   This Week's Tip: Power Up Your Profile!  🚀 It's where every Community member gets their start, and it's essential that you keep it updated! Your Community User Profile is how you're able to get messages, post solutions, ask questions--and as you rank up, it's where your badges will appear and how you'll be known when you start blogging in the Community Blog. Your Community User Profile is how the Community knows you--so it's essential that it works the way you need it to! From changing your username to updating contact information, this Knowledge Base Article is your best resource for powering up your profile.     Password Puzzles? No Problem! Find out how to sync your Azure AD password with your community account, ensuring a seamless sign-in. No separate passwords to remember! Job Jumps & Email Swaps Changed jobs? Got a new email? Fear not! You'll find out how to link your shiny new email to your existing community account, keeping your contributions and connections intact. Username Uncertainties Unraveled Picking the perfect username is crucial--and sometimes the original choice you signed up with doesn't fit as well as you may have thought. There's a quick way to request an update here--but remember, your username is your community identity, so choose wisely. "Need Admin Approval" Warning Window? If you see this error message while using the community, don't worry. A simple process will help you get where you need to go. If you still need assistance, find out how to contact your Community Support team. Whatever you're looking for, when it comes to your profile, the Community Account Support Knowledge Base article is your treasure trove of tips as you navigate the nuances of your Community Profile. It’s the ultimate resource for keeping your digital identity in tip-top shape while engaging with the Power Platform Community. So, dive in and power up your profile today!  💪🚀   Community Account Support | Power Apps Community Account Support | Power AutomateCommunity Account Support | Copilot Studio  Community Account Support | Power Pages

Super User of the Month | Chris Piasecki

In our 2nd installment of this new ongoing feature in the Community, we're thrilled to announce that Chris Piasecki is our Super User of the Month for March 2024. If you've been in the Community for a while, we're sure you've seen a comment or marked one of Chris' helpful tips as a solution--he's been a Super User for SEVEN consecutive seasons!       Since authoring his first reply in April 2020 to his most recent achievement organizing the Canadian Power Platform Summit this month, Chris has helped countless Community members with his insights and expertise. In addition to being a Super User, Chris is also a User Group leader, Microsoft MVP, and a featured speaker at the Microsoft Power Platform Conference. His contributions to the new SUIT program, along with his joyous personality and willingness to jump in and help so many members has made Chris a fixture in the Power Platform Community.   When Chris isn't authoring solutions or organizing events, he's actively leading Piasecki Consulting, specializing in solution architecture, integration, DevOps, and more--helping clients discover how to strategize and implement Microsoft's technology platforms. We are grateful for Chris' insightful help in the Community and look forward to even more amazing milestones as he continues to assist so many with his great tips, solutions--always with a smile and a great sense of humor.You can find Chris in the Community and on LinkedIn. Thanks for being such a SUPER user, Chris! 💪🌠

Find Out What Makes Super Users So Super

We know many of you visit the Power Platform Communities to ask questions and receive answers. But do you know that many of our best answers and solutions come from Community members who are super active, helping anyone who needs a little help getting unstuck with Business Applications products? We call these dedicated Community members Super Users because they are the real heroes in the Community, willing to jump in whenever they can to help! Maybe you've encountered them yourself and they've solved some of your biggest questions. Have you ever wondered, "Why?"We interviewed several of our Super Users to understand what drives them to help in the Community--and discover the difference it has made in their lives as well! Take a look in our gallery today: What Motivates a Super User? - Power Platform Community (microsoft.com)

March User Group Update: New Groups and Upcoming Events!

  Welcome to this month’s celebration of our Community User Groups and exciting User Group events. We’re thrilled to introduce some brand-new user groups that have recently joined our vibrant community. Plus, we’ve got a lineup of engaging events you won’t want to miss. Let’s jump right in: New User Groups   Sacramento Power Platform GroupANZ Power Platform COE User GroupPower Platform MongoliaPower Platform User Group OmanPower Platform User Group Delta StateMid Michigan Power Platform Upcoming Events  DUG4MFG - Quarterly Meetup - Microsoft Demand PlanningDate: 19 Mar 2024 | 10:30 AM to 12:30 PM Central America Standard TimeDescription: Dive into the world of manufacturing with a focus on Demand Planning. Learn from industry experts and share your insights. Dynamics User Group HoustonDate: 07 Mar 2024 | 11:00 AM to 01:00 PM Central America Standard TimeDescription: Houston, get ready for an immersive session on Dynamics 365 and the Power Platform. Connect with fellow professionals and expand your knowledge. Reading Dynamics 365 & Power Platform User Group (Q1)Date: 05 Mar 2024 | 06:00 PM to 09:00 PM GMT Standard TimeDescription: Join our virtual meetup for insightful discussions, demos, and community updates. Let’s kick off Q1 with a bang! Leaders, Create Your Events!    Leaders of existing User Groups, don’t forget to create your events within the Community platform. By doing so, you’ll enable us to share them in future posts and newsletters. Let’s spread the word and make these gatherings even more impactful! Stay tuned for more updates, inspiring stories, and collaborative opportunities from and for our Community User Groups.   P.S. Have an event or success story to share? Reach out to us – we’d love to feature you!

Top Solution Authors
Top Kudoed Authors
Users online (5,624)