cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Reply
AccuFloDev
Advocate II
Advocate II

Help with LookUp Columns - CDS Entities returning null data for lookups in PowerApps

Hello,

 

I've posted about this twice before over the past month with no answer from anyone from Microsoft, and now my project is way behind.

I have a PowerApp Canvas App I'm developing with the new CDS for Apps.
One of my custom entities has six lookup columns which I'm trying to load into a form from a Gallery.

When I open an item from the Gallery in a Form, most of the time it WILL NOT load LookUp data.
When I try to display the lookup information in the "DefaultSelectedItems" function, it is blank because the lookup data is blank.

When I compare the data of the Entity Row to what's in the database, it shows values for the lookups.
However, in the app it is 'blank'.  

This issue comes and goes (sometimes it works, usually it does not) and I can't make heads or tails of it.

How can I query for a specific entity row and ensure that ALL the columns, including the lookup columns, have data in them?  Is this an issue that is Microsoft is aware of, or is it possibly something I'm doing wrong?

27 REPLIES 27
TimRohr
Solution Sage
Solution Sage

I don't think it is just you. I am having a very similar issue.

Given 2 entities, Regions and RegionalGroups, where a Region has many RegionalGroups, I have a relationship between them:

Regions: {RegionName, RegionDescription}

RegionalGroups: {Region [as Lookup field], GroupName}

 

In a form or gallery displaying the RegionalGroups data, I should be able to reference the RegionName through that lookup field:

ThisItem.Region.RegionName

This will pass the syntax check, but most times it pulls in blank data. I've tried using "Value" for the lookup field as some older posts mention, but it is apparently no longer accepted by the compiler:

ThisItem.Region.Value   <----Produces RedX

I have had somewhat better luck with the LookUp() function, but even that gives me blank results sometimes, especially if a third entity is involved (where RegionalGroups are used in many Roles).

 

Role: {RegionalGroup [as Lookup field], Employee [as Lookup field], RoleName,...}

 

If I select the Role in a gallery and I want to store the Region, I should be able to do a LookUp against the RegionalGroup associated with the Role, and return the RegionName. For instance, I can return the RoleName with the LookUp:

LookUp(RegionalGroups, RegionalGroup = RolesForEmployee_BrowseGallery.Selected.RegionalGroup.RegionalGroup, RoleName)

But I CAN'T return the LookUp field through the LookUp() function:

LookUp(RegionalGroups, RegionalGroup = RolesForEmployee_BrowseGallery.Selected.RegionalGroup.RegionalGroup, Region.RegionName)

That, again, passes the syntax checker, but it returns blank.

 

 

Hey @TimRohr,

 

Good to know it's not just me.

Based on some blog entries I've read, PowerApps is supposed to 'intelligently' decide which columns to select.
In practice however, it does not seem to work very well at all.

TimRohr
Solution Sage
Solution Sage

@AccuFloDev, I just had a conversation with a PowerApps escalation engineer about my issue with LookUp columns returning blank data.

 

If it helps you, we converted my Lookup() formulas trying to pull in data from the LookUP columns into First(Filter()) statements, and it worked.

 

So, as an example, if my statement used to be:

Lookup(RegionalGroups,RegionalGroup=GroupID,Region.Region)

We changed it to:

First(Filter(RegionalGroups,RegionalGroup=GroupID)).Region.Region

And that pulled it in.

 

He said he'd seen where LookUp() doesn't always pull the data properly, and if it doesn't get it, it returns a blank, which is what I was seeing (and it sounds like you were, too).

 

Try that and see if it helps you.

Hey @TimRohr,

 

I did find the same behaviour as you did, where the First(Filter()) method would get what I wanted but not always.
A more reliable method I have found is (if this design is applicable) to do something like this:

 

  1. Use a Gallery control to select your item(s) to be opened in a Form

  2. Make sure the Gallery control template has every LookUp field you intend on using in the form displayed in a Label or similar control (The label does not need to be visible, just part of the Gallery Template).

    For example, if an Entity has a One-To-Many relationship, I would show something like Text = Text(CountRows(Entity.YourLookupColumn))

  3. Repeat for every LookUp column necessary

  4. When selecting an item to display on a form, make sure you pass it to the Form using ThisItem.Selected from the Gallery

By using the Gallery Control, PowerApps seems to use the Template to determine what data it needs to pull into the form.  I tested this by using one with the LookUp columns in the template, and one without.  The Gallery without the LookUp columns in the Template consistently returned empty data for Lookups.

 

Hopefully this workaround helps someone until MS can get the bugs ironed out of the current version.

Interesting that First(Filter()) didn't always pull the data for you, either. So far mine has been consistent, but I will have to watch for that.

 

I worried that a workaround like yours would be the solution. I was really hoping to avoid that length of a workaround just to get consistent returns from the datasource. Smiley Frustrated

KelvinBox
Frequent Visitor

6 months on and this is still a major problem!

It works sporadically and most of the hacks provided by Microsoft to make it work seem to only work 95% of the time... not good enough.

How do we find out if a real fix is being worked on?

Having the exact same issue here.

The CDS connection is touted as the better option, yet I am unable to retrieve any data that is a lookup.  Always comes through as blank.

At least with the Dynamics 365 connection I get the lookup data, but I lose a ton of capabilities.

When is a Microsoft PowerApps Dev Team resource going to respond to this? Or do I have to log a Service Request?

We have a service request open for it now, just waiting for it to be addressed.
jzcase
Responsive Resident
Responsive Resident

Reporting same problem here. Not just LookUp() but also ClearCollect() pulls null values for lookup fields! Ridiculous!

Helpful resources

Announcements

Take a short Community User Survey | Help us make your experience better!

To ensure that we are providing the best possible experience for Community members, we want to hear from you!    We value your feedback! As part of our commitment to enhancing your experience, we invite you to participate in a brief 15-question survey. Your insights will help us improve our services and better serve the community.   👉 Community User Survey    Thank you for being an essential part of our community!    Power Platform Engagement Team  

Tuesday Tip | How to Get Community Support

It's time for another Tuesday Tip, your weekly connection with the most insightful tips and tricks that empower both newcomers and veterans in the Power Platform Community! Every Tuesday, we bring you a curated selection of the finest advice, distilled from the resources and tools in the Community. Whether you’re a seasoned member or just getting started, Tuesday Tips are the perfect compass guiding you across the dynamic landscape of the Power Platform Community.       This Week: All About Community Support Whether you're a seasoned community veteran or just getting started, you may need a bit of help from time to time! If you need to share feedback with the Community Engagement team about the community or are looking for ways we can assist you with user groups, events, or something else, Community Support is the place to start.   Community Support is part of every one of our communities, accessible to all our community members.   Within each community's Community Support page, you'll find three distinct areas, each with a different focus to help you when you need support from us most. Power Apps: https://powerusers.microsoft.com/t5/Community-Support/ct-p/pa_community_support Power Automate: https://powerusers.microsoft.com/t5/Community-Support/ct-p/mpa_community_support Power Pages: https://powerusers.microsoft.com/t5/Community-Support/ct-p/mpp_community_support Copilot Studio: https://powerusers.microsoft.com/t5/Community-Support/ct-p/pva_community-support   Community Support Form If you need more assistance, you can reach out to the Community Team via the Community support form. Choose the type of support you require and fill in the form accordingly. We will respond to you promptly.    Thank you for being an active part of our community. Your contributions make a difference!   Best Regards, The Community Management Team

Community Roundup: A Look Back at Our Last 10 Tuesday Tips

As we continue to grow and learn together, it's important to reflect on the valuable insights we've shared. For today's #TuesdayTip, we're excited to take a moment to look back at the last 10 tips we've shared in case you missed any or want to revisit them. Thanks for your incredible support for this series--we're so glad it was able to help so many of you navigate your community experience!   Getting Started in the Community An overview of everything you need to know about navigating the community on one page!  Community Links: ○ Power Apps ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Community Ranks and YOU Have you ever wondered how your fellow community members ascend the ranks within our community? We explain everything about ranks and how to achieve points so you can climb up in the rankings! Community Links: ○ Power Apps ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Powering Up Your Community Profile Your Community User Profile is how the Community knows you--so it's essential that it works the way you need it to! From changing your username to updating contact information, this Knowledge Base Article is your best resource for powering up your profile. Community Links: ○ Power Apps ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Community Blogs--A Great Place to Start There's so much you'll discover in the Community Blogs, and we hope you'll check them out today!  Community Links: ○ Power Apps ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Unlocking Community Achievements and Earning Badges Across the Communities, you'll see badges on users profile that recognize and reward their engagement and contributions. Check out some details on Community badges--and find out more in the detailed link at the end of the article! Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio    Blogging in the Community Interested in blogging? Everything you need to know on writing blogs in our four communities! Get started blogging across the Power Platform communities today! Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Subscriptions & Notifications We don't want you to miss a thing in the community! Read all about how to subscribe to sections of our forums and how to setup your notifications! Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Getting Started with Private Messages & Macros Do you want to enhance your communication in the Community and streamline your interactions? One of the best ways to do this is to ensure you are using Private Messaging--and the ever-handy macros that are available to you as a Community member! Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Community User Groups Learn everything about being part of, starting, or leading a User Group in the Power Platform Community. Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Update Your Community Profile Today! Keep your community profile up to date which is essential for staying connected and engaged with the community. Community Links: ○ Power Apps  ○ Power Automate  ○ Power Pages  ○ Copilot Studio   Thank you for being an integral part of our journey.   Here's to many more Tuesday Tips as we pave the way for a brighter, more connected future! As always, watch the News & Announcements for the next set of tips, coming soon!

Calling all User Group Leaders and Super Users! Mark Your Calendars for the next Community Ambassador Call on May 9th!

This month's Community Ambassador call is on May 9th at 9a & 3p PDT. Please keep an eye out in your private messages and Teams channels for your invitation. There are lots of exciting updates coming to the Community, and we have some exclusive opportunities to share with you! As always, we'll also review regular updates for User Groups, Super Users, and share general information about what's going on in the Community.     Be sure to register & we hope to see all of you there!

April 2024 Community Newsletter

We're pleased to share the April Community Newsletter, where we highlight the latest news, product releases, upcoming events, and the amazing work of our outstanding Community members.   If you're new to the Community, please make sure to follow the latest News & Announcements and check out the Community on LinkedIn as well! It's the best way to stay up-to-date with all the news from across Microsoft Power Platform and beyond.    COMMUNITY HIGHLIGHTS   Check out the most active community members of the last month! These hardworking members are posting regularly, answering questions, kudos, and providing top solutions in their communities. We are so thankful for each of you--keep up the great work! If you hope to see your name here next month, follow these awesome community members to see what they do!   Power AppsPower AutomateCopilot StudioPower PagesWarrenBelzDeenujialexander2523ragavanrajanLaurensMManishSolankiMattJimisonLucas001AmikcapuanodanilostephenrobertOliverRodriguestimlAndrewJManikandanSFubarmmbr1606VishnuReddy1997theMacResolutionsVishalJhaveriVictorIvanidzejsrandhawahagrua33ikExpiscornovusFGuerrero1PowerAddictgulshankhuranaANBExpiscornovusprathyooSpongYeNived_Nambiardeeksha15795apangelesGochixgrantjenkinsvasu24Mfon   LATEST NEWS Business Applications Launch Event - On Demand In case you missed the Business Applications Launch Event, you can now catch up on all the announcements and watch the entire event on-demand inside Charles Lamanna's latest cloud blog.   This is your one stop shop for all the latest Copilot features across Power Platform and #Dynamics365, including first-hand looks at how companies such as Lenovo, Sonepar, Ford Motor Company, Omnicom and more are using these new capabilities in transformative ways. Click the image below to watch today!     Power Platform Community Conference 2024 is here! It's time to look forward to the next installment of the Power Platform Community Conference, which takes place this year on 18-20th September 2024 at the MGM Grand in Las Vegas!   Come and be inspired by Microsoft senior thought leaders and the engineers behind the #PowerPlatform, with Charles Lamanna, Sangya Singh, Ryan Cunningham, Kim Manis, Nirav Shah, Omar Aftab and Leon Welicki already confirmed to speak. You'll also be able to learn from industry experts and Microsoft MVPs who are dedicated to bridging the gap between humanity and technology. These include the likes of Lisa Crosbie, Victor Dantas, Kristine Kolodziejski, David Yack, Daniel Christian, Miguel Félix, and Mats Necker, with many more to be announced over the coming weeks.   Click here to watch our brand-new sizzle reel for #PPCC24 or click the image below to find out more about registration. See you in Vegas!     Power Up Program Announces New Video-Based Learning Hear from Principal Program Manager, Dimpi Gandhi, to discover the latest enhancements to the Microsoft #PowerUpProgram. These include a new accelerated video-based curriculum crafted with the expertise of Microsoft MVPs, Rory Neary and Charlie Phipps-Bennett. If you’d like to hear what’s coming next, click the image below to find out more!     UPCOMING EVENTS Microsoft Build - Seattle and Online - 21-23rd May 2024 Taking place on 21-23rd May 2024 both online and in Seattle, this is the perfect event to learn more about low code development, creating copilots, cloud platforms, and so much more to help you unleash the power of AI.   There's a serious wealth of talent speaking across the three days, including the likes of Satya Nadella, Amanda K. Silver, Scott Guthrie, Sarah Bird, Charles Lamanna, Miti J., Kevin Scott, Asha Sharma, Rajesh Jha, Arun Ulag, Clay Wesener, and many more.   And don't worry if you can't make it to Seattle, the event will be online and totally free to join. Click the image below to register for #MSBuild today!     European Collab Summit - Germany - 14-16th May 2024 The clock is counting down to the amazing European Collaboration Summit, which takes place in Germany May 14-16, 2024. #CollabSummit2024 is designed to provide cutting-edge insights and best practices into Power Platform, Microsoft 365, Teams, Viva, and so much more. There's a whole host of experts speakers across the three-day event, including the likes of Vesa Juvonen, Laurie Pottmeyer, Dan Holme, Mark Kashman, Dona Sarkar, Gavin Barron, Emily Mancini, Martina Grom, Ahmad Najjar, Liz Sundet, Nikki Chapple, Sara Fennah, Seb Matthews, Tobias Martin, Zoe Wilson, Fabian Williams, and many more.   Click the image below to find out more about #ECS2024 and register today!   Microsoft 365 & Power Platform Conference - Seattle - 3-7th June If you're looking to turbo boost your Power Platform skills this year, why not take a look at everything TechCon365 has to offer at the Seattle Convention Center on June 3-7, 2024.   This amazing 3-day conference (with 2 optional days of workshops) offers over 130 sessions across multiple tracks, alongside 25 workshops presented by Power Platform, Microsoft 365, Microsoft Teams, Viva, Azure, Copilot and AI experts. There's a great array of speakers, including the likes of Nirav Shah, Naomi Moneypenny, Jason Himmelstein, Heather Cook, Karuana Gatimu, Mark Kashman, Michelle Gilbert, Taiki Y., Kristi K., Nate Chamberlain, Julie Koesmarno, Daniel Glenn, Sarah Haase, Marc Windle, Amit Vasu, Joanne C Klein, Agnes Molnar, and many more.   Click the image below for more #Techcon365 intel and register today!   For more events, click the image below to visit the Microsoft Community Days website.    

Tuesday Tip | Update Your Community Profile Today!

It's time for another TUESDAY TIPS, your weekly connection with the most insightful tips and tricks that empower both newcomers and veterans in the Power Platform Community! Every Tuesday, we bring you a curated selection of the finest advice, distilled from the resources and tools in the Community. Whether you’re a seasoned member or just getting started, Tuesday Tips are the perfect compass guiding you across the dynamic landscape of the Power Platform Community.   We're excited to announce that updating your community profile has never been easier! Keeping your profile up to date is essential for staying connected and engaged with the community.   Check out the following Support Articles with these topics: Accessing Your Community ProfileRetrieving Your Profile URLUpdating Your Community Profile Time ZoneChanging Your Community Profile Picture (Avatar)Setting Your Date Display Preferences Click on your community link for more information: Power Apps, Power Automate, Power Pages, Copilot Studio   Thank you for being an active part of our community. Your contributions make a difference! Best Regards, The Community Management Team

Users online (4,274)